EU Digital Fairness Act Could Reshape Consumer Protection Rules Across Europe

17 November 2026

The European Union is preparing a potentially significant overhaul of consumer protection legislation that could affect businesses operating online platforms, subscription services, digital advertising and consumer-facing sales channels. The proposed Digital Fairness Act (DFA), published by the European Commission on 11 November 2026, would replace the existing Unfair Commercial Practices Directive with a directly applicable EU regulation, introducing more consistent rules across member states while expanding oversight of digital commercial practices.

The proposed legislation goes beyond addressing misleading online interfaces, commonly known as dark patterns. It would retain existing protections against unfair and aggressive commercial practices while introducing additional requirements covering personalised advertising, subscription management, influencer marketing, artificial intelligence and automated transactions. Its scope would extend to business-to-consumer activities conducted both online and offline.

According to legal analysis published by international law firm CMS on 16 November, the proposed legislation represents a substantial change in the structure of European consumer law. Rather than relying on national legislation implementing an EU directive, the DFA would establish a common regulatory framework directly applicable across the bloc. The proposal remains subject to negotiations and approval by the European Parliament and the Council, meaning its final provisions could change.

One of the principal objectives is to address commercial practices that influence consumer decisions through website design, automated recommendations and behavioural techniques. These include misleading countdown timers, artificial scarcity messages, confusing purchasing processes and interfaces that make it unnecessarily difficult to cancel subscriptions or decline additional services.

The proposal would introduce a general prohibition on online interfaces that deceive or manipulate consumers in ways that materially distort their behaviour. It would also establish a list of prohibited practices that could be updated through delegated legislation. For businesses, this would increase scrutiny of how digital services are designed, rather than focusing solely on whether the information presented to customers is factually accurate.

The legislation would operate alongside existing EU regulations, including the Digital Services Act, Digital Markets Act, General Data Protection Regulation and AI Act. However, CMS identifies potential uncertainty where several regulatory frameworks apply to the same commercial activity. In particular, the relationship between the Digital Fairness Act and existing restrictions on manipulative online interfaces under the Digital Services Act could create overlapping responsibilities for regulators.

Enforcement could become considerably more significant. Under the accompanying proposed reforms to the Consumer Protection Cooperation framework, the European Commission would receive stronger powers to investigate certain large-scale cross-border infringements. In cases investigated by the Commission under that framework, financial penalties could reach up to 6% of a company’s worldwide annual turnover.

The proposed rules could also require businesses to provide evidence explaining how digital interfaces were developed, tested and approved. Internal design documents, consumer behaviour testing and records of decisions concerning advertising or purchasing processes may therefore become relevant during regulatory investigations.

Subscription services are another major focus. The DFA would introduce requirements for reminders and explicit consent before free trials convert into paid subscriptions, alongside clearer renewal notifications and online cancellation functions. Consumers would also receive stronger protections concerning withdrawal rights and access to human customer service when automated systems fail to resolve their concerns.

These provisions could affect a broad range of businesses, including digital service providers, telecommunications operators, online retailers and companies offering recurring consumer contracts. The implications may also extend to property-related platforms providing paid listings, subscriptions or other consumer services, depending on their business models and the final wording of the legislation.

Artificial intelligence and automated purchasing systems would face additional obligations. The proposal would require consumers to retain control over important transaction parameters, including spending limits and prior confirmation requirements. Businesses would also be prohibited from making the use of automated purchasing agents compulsory for accessing or concluding consumer transactions.

Personalised advertising and pricing would receive greater scrutiny, particularly where vulnerable consumers or minors could be affected. The proposal would restrict certain profiling-based advertising practices and prohibit personalised pricing where it is reasonably likely to harm children or vulnerable consumers.

Influencer marketing would also be subject to clearer disclosure requirements. Commercial partnerships would need to be identified prominently, while responsibility for compliance could extend beyond individual influencers to the brands, advertisers and agencies involved in promotional campaigns.

The proposed legislation also addresses digital services designed to encourage prolonged engagement. Features such as infinite scrolling and autoplay would not be prohibited outright for adults, but businesses could be required to provide effective options for disabling mechanisms associated with compulsive or excessive use. Online gaming and virtual currencies would face additional transparency requirements, including disclosure of real-money values and restrictions on certain monetisation practices involving minors.

The Netherlands provides an example of how the new framework could interact with established national enforcement practices. The Dutch Authority for Consumers and Markets has already taken action against misleading digital interfaces, artificial discounts and commercial practices affecting online gaming. Dutch authorities have also advocated stronger enforcement of existing EU rules while emphasising the need to avoid unnecessary regulatory duplication.

For businesses operating across multiple European markets, a directly applicable regulation could reduce some differences between national consumer protection regimes. However, it could also introduce new compliance costs, particularly for companies that rely heavily on personalised marketing, automated customer interactions or complex digital purchasing processes.

The implications extend beyond technology companies. Retailers, hospitality operators, residential property platforms and other consumer-facing businesses increasingly depend on digital booking systems, online payments, promotional offers and subscription-based services. Practices previously regarded primarily as marketing or user-experience decisions may become more directly exposed to regulatory scrutiny.

For the real estate sector, the most immediate relevance is likely to concern businesses providing services directly to individual consumers, including residential sales and rental platforms, accommodation booking services and digital property marketplaces. Commercial property transactions between businesses would generally fall outside the proposal’s central business-to-consumer framework.

The legislative process is still at an early stage, and the eventual balance between consumer protection, administrative requirements and regulatory overlap remains uncertain. Nevertheless, the proposal indicates that EU policymakers are seeking to move beyond regulating misleading advertising alone towards examining the wider digital environment in which consumers make purchasing decisions.

If adopted, the Digital Fairness Act could become one of the EU’s most consequential changes to consumer protection law in recent years. Its significance will depend not only on the final restrictions imposed on businesses, but also on whether the new framework delivers more consistent enforcement without creating additional uncertainty alongside existing digital legislation.

Source: CMS

front page info
LATEST NEWS